“Roger Stone Did Nothing Wrong!” proclaimed the T-shirts worn by his supporters. Federal prosecutors, by contrast, argued that Stone deserved at least seven years in prison.
US District Judge Amy Berman Jackson split the difference last week, sentencing the longtime President Trump crony to three years and four months in prison — a penalty that still seems excessive given the nature and consequences of his crimes. Indeed, the case highlights the dubious wisdom and fairness of federal sentencing guidelines.
When Attorney General William Barr overrode the original sentencing recommendation, which called for a prison term of seven to nine years, the resulting controversy focused on the appearance that he was acting at his boss’s behest.
But whatever Barr’s motive, his memo raised legitimate concerns about penalties imposed on federal defendants.
Stone was convicted of lying to Congress about his attempts to help elect Trump by contacting WikiLeaks, which had obtained emails that Russian hackers stole from the Democratic National Committee. He was also convicted of witness tampering, because he persistently pressured his erstwhile friend Randy Credico, one of his WikiLeaks intermediaries, to refrain from contradicting those lies.
Contrary to the claims made by some of Stone’s defenders, he didn’t stumble into a “perjury trap” set by the president’s enemies. When he voluntarily testified before the House Intelligence Committee, which was investigating Russian attempts to influence the 2016 election, the panel was controlled by Republicans, and the chairman was Rep. Devin Nunes (R-Calif.), a Trump ally.
Stone easily could have avoided his legal troubles by declining to testify or by telling the truth. Instead, he lied, repeatedly and flagrantly, about his contacts with people he thought could relay messages to WikiLeaks, about his communications with Trump campaign officials and about the emails and text messages that documented those interactions.
Having lied, Stone persistently pressured Credico to back up his story or avoid testifying. When Credico received a subpoena, he invoked the Fifth Amendment, as Stone had suggested.
Jackson indignantly rejected the idea that none of this was a big deal, and she had a point. Unless you think Congress has no business holding hearings on issues such as foreign meddling in US elections, it seems clear that witnesses at those hearings can’t be allowed to lie with impunity.
Yet the actions Stone tried to conceal, while potentially embarrassing to the president, were neither criminal nor consequential, and the facts eventually emerged despite his dishonesty. And while the assistant US attorneys who prosecuted Stone argued that he deserved a hefty sentencing enhancement for threatening Credico with violence, Credico himself implored Jackson not to impose a prison sentence, emphasizing that he never took the defendant’s bluster seriously.
In addition to making that point, the amended sentencing memorandum questioned “the two-level enhancement for obstruction of justice,” which was based mainly on Stone’s public statements about his case. While conceding that the enhancements recommended by Stone’s prosecutors were “arguably” consistent with the guidelines and “perhaps technically applicable,” the second (Barr) memo argued that the resulting sentencing range was disproportionate for nonviolent crimes.
The memo noted that prosecutors have a duty to pursue justice, not simply to clobber defendants with the heaviest penalties the law allows. It thereby called attention to the disjunction between just punishment and the sentences recommended by the guidelines, which have long been criticized as excessively harsh, mechanical and complicated — yet blind to relevant moral differences.
“Many defense attorneys and judges have been making that point for a very long time,” Jackson noted, “but we usually don’t succeed in getting the government to agree.” The problems with the guidelines are real and troubling, even in cases that don’t involve the president’s pals.
- BREAKING: Explosion destroys 100 houses, schools, churches in Akure
- Explosion Rocks Akure, Destroys School, Church Others
- Corona criminals’ prey on Europe’s virus fears
- Civil Rights leader Joseph Lowery dead at 98
- Cycling movie ‘Breaking Away’ is a sports classic
- COVID-19: China Donates Medical Equipment To Nigeria
- Traditional Ruler Tells Govt To Engage Native Doctors Against COVID-19
- Makinde Sacks Aide Over False Information On Social Media
- Update: Police officers caught on camera destroying goods of traders in Lagos have been identified and subjected to disciplinary proceedings
- Spain boss Enrique not ruling out Barcelona return
- COVID-19: US Set To Evacuate Citizens In Nigeria
- Civil war, great flood looming – Apostle Okikijesu makes fresh prophecy on Nigeria
- Comedian Sydney Talker Cries For Help, Shows COVID-19 Symptoms
- BREAKING: Explosion rocks Ondo, hundreds of buildings destroyed
- Enugu closes its borders after becoming the first South-East state with cases of coronavirus
- Uncle on the run after allegedly killing his 7-year-old twin nephews for money rituals in Delta
- How Oregon became NCAA Tournament’s original Cinderella
- Consult native doctors, soothsayers for solution to coronavirus – Monarch tells FG
- Coronavirus: Avoid AC, Only Four Persons In Cars – VIO
- Shipments of urns in Wuhan raise questions about China’s coronavirus reporting
- Latest Coronavirus Update For Today, Friday, March 27th, 2020
- Latest Biafra News Online Update Today Friday, March 27th 2020
- COVID-19: President Buhari hails Atiku Abubakar, Dangote, Otedola, Elemelu, others
- Nigerian Newspapers: Top 10 Headlines Friday, March 27th, 2020
- COVID-19: Umahi bans release of corpses, orders arrest of policemen, family members for conducting burial in Ebonyi
- COVID -19: Nnamdi Kanu reveals where Abba Kyari was secretly flown for Coronavirus treatment
- New Yorker singing out window told to ‘Shut the f— up!’
- Woman stabbed to death in NYC hotel lobby
- Nigerians Remind T.B Joshua Of His Prophesy That Coronavirus Will Disappear By March 27
- Davido’s Fiancée, Chioma Tests Positive For Coronavirus
- Coronavirus: Nigerian Ports Authority calls out NCDC over claims of detecting new cases on a vessel in Lagos
- COVID-19: Femi Adesina opens up on Buhari, other happenings in Aso Rock
- [Breaking] COVID-19: Davido’s girlfriend, Chioma, tests positive
- Coronavirus: Time to come together – Muslim Rights
- COVID-19: US Asks Foreign Doctors, Nurses To Reach Out For Work Visas
- Father kills son for beheading his mother in Enugu
- Zamfara Guber tussle: PDP reacts as Gov. Matawalle wins APC in Supreme Court
- The North Face offers 25% off entire purchase for spring sale
- WWE’s Roman Reigns pulls out of WrestleMania 36 due to coronavirus concerns
- Gunmen Kidnap Man After Forcing Wife To Cook Jollof Rice
- Coronavirus: Nine suspected Covid-19 cases in Kano test negative
- Hoda Kotb cries on ‘Today’ show about Drew Brees’ $5M donation to Louisiana
- BREAKING: Coronavirus cases in Nigeria hit 70
- I tested positive for Coronavirus – Ogun ex-Sports Commissioner, Olopade [Video]
- Bob Dylan releases 17-minute song about John F. Kennedy assassination
- 2020 UTME: JAMB Hands Over 180 Candidates To Police
- Teen football player Jaquan Anderson dead from coronavirus in New Orleans
- Fire guts NYSC camp in Rivers
- Covid-19: Despite scourge, Muslim faithful observe jumaat congregational prayers in Kano
- Baby tiger born at zoo in Mexico named ‘Covid’
- Hypo Bleach Slashes Price To Encourage Safer Environment Against Covid-19
- Coronavirus: FCT Minister reveals new measures to control spread of COVID-19
- Comedian Seyi Law and his wife celebrate 9th wedding anniversary
- COVID-19: Nigeria lacks capacity to contain coronavirus on large scale – Pastor Tunde Bakare
- Sanwo-Olu Is 10 Times Better Than You Are – Omokri Writes Buhari
- Lagos confirms pipeline leakage, alerts Nigerians
- Coronavirus: Isolate if you visited our Abuja office this week – Smile Nigeria
- Coronavirus : LUTH makes clarification on ‘turning back” positive patient