Watching the historic agreement normalizing relations between Israel and two Arab states at the White House — an event neither I nor anyone else who has watched the Middle East closely for the past half-century ever really thought would happen — I had to acknowledge to myself how wrong I had been.
Back in 2018, when Team Trump announced it was going to move the US Embassy in Israel to Jerusalem from Tel Aviv, I didn’t think it was all that big a deal — even though I was and remain a resolute and unconditional supporter of the Jewish state.
I thought it was a nice gesture that acknowledged an undeniable reality, which is that Israel’s capital is Jerusalem. Moreover, the move was fully in keeping with the 1995 law that mandated the embassy move by 1999 — a law the Clinton, Bush and Obama administrations had “suspended” every six months since 1999 on the largely spurious grounds that doing so would pose a danger to our security.
But the move didn’t mean much beyond that, I thought.
Oh, I was wrong — though I’m happy to say I was right in dismissing the doom-and-gloom warnings of the foreign-policy establishment about how destabilizing and dangerous it would be for the United States to make the move.
The idea that the Middle East would turn against Washington and erupt in horrendous street violence was based, I thought, on a dated understanding of the relationship between the Arab world and the Palestinians. Where once the Palestinian cause was a binding glue of pan-Arab nationalism, time and politics had marched on and left the sclerotic, unchanging, uncreative and disempowered Palestinians behind.
Israel’s working relationships behind the scenes with once-key benefactors of the Palestinians — the Saudis in particular — made me think there would be no sponsorship of those street riots by regional powers. That proved to be correct.
Where I was wrong, and where I think many people are wrong even among those who are giving the Trump administration proper credit for its diplomatic triumph, is in failing to grasp the world-historic significance of the embassy move in 2018.
When the world’s most powerful country recognized Israel’s sovereign control over Jerusalem, it finally and formally moved past the now-fanciful notion, dating back to 1947, that the city ought to be governed by some transnational entity.
The international status of Jerusalem was part of the original UN design of the partition of the British Mandate intended to create homelands for the Jews and for Palestinian Arabs. The Jews said yes. The Arabs said no and launched a war to destroy the Jews.
Great plan, no?
Anyway, because of the particular circumstances governing Israel’s inception as a nation, its enemies have comforted themselves with the idea that it had been externally imposed on the region and was, therefore, essentially temporary.
What had been given to the Jews by the United Nations could be taken away. Israel hadn’t been there before. It could go away again.
The idea of Israel’s potential impermanence is why Palestinians still cling to the notion that they will somehow be able to push the Jews into the sea and control the entire area from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean. It is why Iranian leaders, from ex-President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to head mullah Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, love to trumpet the idea that Israel will “disappear.”
And it is why the blanket resistance in the Arab world to the idea that Israel had dominion over Jerusalem — first in the western part of the city and then, after its victory in the 1967 Six-Day War, the entirety of it — was so total.
For Jerusalem is, unquestionably, permanent. It is as permanent as — may one dare say it — the Jewish people ourselves. Its continuous existence from time immemorial is the signature fact of the Middle East.
To accept Israeli sovereignty over Jerusalem is therefore to accept Israel’s permanence. And this was something even the United States, Israel’s best (and, at times, only) friend in the world, wasn’t willing to do formally.
And if it wasn’t willing, how could Arab states take the final step to recognize Israel’s existence? If America didn’t fully embrace Israel’s permanence, how could they?
The embassy move was therefore a huge change in what you might call “geopolitical psychology.”
It meant Israel was here to stay forever, and the time had come for Arab nations that want to move forward into the 21st century to accept its existence.
Never have I been happier to be wrong.
New York Post
- Diana French, woman accused of stealing Kyle Richards’ ring, speaks outDiana French has a bone to pick with Kyle Richards. And Diane Keaton, for that matter. French, a retired pharmacy clerk from Los Angeles, wound up an unwitting viral star when “Real Housewives of ...[Read more]
- Amanda Knox joins bid to help NXIVM sex-cult leader Keith RaniereAmanda Knox — whose sensational 2009 murder conviction in Italy was famously overturned — has joined a bid to help NXIVM sex-cult leader Keith Raniere, according to a new report. Knox, aka “Foxy ...[Read more]
- NLC Suspends Nationwide Strike And ProtestThe Nigerian Labour Congress (NLC) has suspended the planned nationwide strike and protest that was slated for today, September 28, over the recent hike in electricity tariff and petrol ...[Read more]
- BBNaija Is Over, Welcome Back To Reality – Peter Okoye To NigeriansADVERTISEMENT Musician Peter Okoye, known by the stage name, Mr P has reminded Nigerians of the challenges in the country after Big Brother Naija ended. The popular reality TV show ended on Sunday ...[Read more]
- A liberal result from Amy Coney Barrett and other commentaryLibertarian: A Liberal Result from ACB The New York Times’ Adam Liptak and others cite Judge Amy Coney Barrett’s opinion in John Doe v. Purdue University as evidence of her “almost uniformly ...[Read more]
- TrikyTee’s childhood friend dies in road accident while allegedly being chased by Shagamu police patrol van (Graphic Photos)A gentleman identified as Richard Wetkos Dayon, who is said to be a longtime friend of BBNaija reality TV star, TrikyTee, lost his life in a car crash while allegedly being chased by a police ...[Read more]
- Verizon scrambling to unload HuffPost as losses mountVerizon has been quietly scrambling to unload HuffPost as it grapples with continued losses at the left-leaning news and culture website, The Post has learned. The telecom giant — which ...[Read more]
- ”Please DO NOT fall for SCAMS” – Dorathy’s management disclaims fake goFundMe account opened in her nameThe management of Big Brother Naija season 5 finalist, Dorathy Bachor, on Monday, took to her Instagram page to warn her fans to ignore any GoFundMe account that was created in her name because they ...[Read more]
- Bobrisky acquires new Mercedes Benz Brabus G63, reportedly worth N140 millionPopular Nigerian cross-dresser, Bobrisky has acquired a brand new Mercedes Benz Brabus G63, which is reported to be worth N140 million. He took to his Instagram page to announce ...[Read more]
- Pierce Brosnan selling James Bond-inspired Malibu house for $100MThis could be a golden buy from the guy who starred in “GoldenEye.” Pierce Brosnan, the 67-year-old Irish-born actor perhaps best known for his leading role in four James Bond movies, has listed his ...[Read more]
- ‘Why So Fine ,Go Joor’ – Female Fan Gushes Over Regina Daniels’ Ex-Fiancee, SomadinaADVERTISEMENT One of the female fans of Regina Daniels’ ex-fiancee, Somadina has gushed over him. This was after the handsome actor shared a photo of himself looking awesome in his shades on his ...[Read more]
- Rema Reveals Why He Performed With A Mask On His First ShowMavins empire singer/rapper, Divine Ikubor popularly known as Rema has revealed why he performed with his mask on his first show. The young musician made this known during his recent rants on ...[Read more]
- “He is passing a message” Don Jazzy reacts to Rema’s outburst on TwitterRema poured out his heart on Twitter on Monday Septebmer 28, and his record label boss, Don Jazzy, has reacted after he was told to take action. Twitter users who were concerned about Rema’s ...[Read more]
- Actress, Iyabo Ojo receives Range Rover gift from her “god daughter” (Photos)Popular Nigerian actress and serial entrepreneur, Iyabo Ojo is now the proud owner of yet another Ranger Rover whip. In a post shared on her Instagram page earlier today, Monday, September ...[Read more]
- Popular Nollywood Actress Gists Ladies On The Best Way To Punish Their FianceesADVERTISEMENT Popular Nollywood actress, Onyii Alex has given a gist to ladies on the best way to punish their fiancees. The beautiful actress gave this controversial advice to her female fans and ...[Read more]
Join The Discussion👇🏾
- on Ini Edo Gets People Worried After Sharing What Her Face Looks Like Currently – PHOTOS I just wish you would trust me to be of assistance Exotic queens beaut…
- on Ini Edo Gets People Worried After Sharing What Her Face Looks Like Currently – PHOTOS Buy Norland paste then rob it 40 mims before each bath
- on FG cries out, says IPOB bent on destroying Nigeria THE LASTING SOLUTION TO NIGERIA IS UNITED STATE OF BIAFRA PERIOD .BUHA…
- on IPOB warns of continuous killing of members by security operatives Well for me ipob is for freedom
- on FG cries out, says IPOB bent on destroying Nigeria Are You sleeping when kanu said he will destroy Nigeria with truth. If…
- on ‘I Feel Beautiful When I Do Braids’- Tiwa Savage Reveals As She Shows Off New Hairstyle (PHOTO) Timeless beauty ageless too she is always pretty
- on BBNaija: “Ozo’s Family Doesn’t Want Nengi”- See What His Sister Posted Online That Got People Talking What ozo sister did is wrong. Why would she say that forgetting that N…
- on Breaking!!! Kanu Promises to Drop Biafra Agitation on One Condition Rape: (Apart from people who rape with occuitic power with small girl…
- on #BBNaija: “I’m a big fan, this guy sweet die” – Mercy Eke gushes over Prince (Video) Med oooo🤨🤨🤨😁😁🤣🤣🤣🤣
- on Laycon Finally Makes Housemates Understand Why He Wears Sweater And Socks 24/7 And It’s Heartbreaking- See Reactions From Nigerians Aww sorry laycon